Quidditch Captain (was Re: Will Ginny be a prefect?)
jlv230
jlv230 at yahoo.co.uk
Tue Jun 28 08:39:17 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 131590
> JLV:
> The obvious choice for captain is Harry (as star player and longest
> serving member)
>
> Melissa:
> Actually Katie Bell is the longest serving player on the team. She
> was already there when Harry joined in his first year. Oliver Wood
> left after Harry's 3rd year. Fred, George, Angelina and Alicia are
> left (or were leaving) at the end of Harry's 5th year. Leaving
> Katie Bell as the Senior player left from Harry's 1st year. For
> that reason alone I think that Katie will get it.
>
Hmm - Katie is only a year older than Harry. That means she must
either have joined at the same time as Harry or she played in her
first year. Neither of which seem to be the case... but I still can't
find my copy of PS. Can someone confirm what the situation is there?
Yet, consulting OotP, Ginny does only mention Angelina and Alicia
leaving (I had thought the three girls were in the same year for some
strange reason - hence my comment). I hope you can see how I got
confused!
I still want Ron to be captain. But perhaps he'll have to wait until
his last year at Hogwarts...
JLV xx
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive