Harry doesn't know Re: Lifespans?
potioncat
willsonkmom at msn.com
Wed Jun 29 12:18:29 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 131649
Potioncat asked:
> >And another thought just crossed my mind; I wonder how many of the
old Headmasters DD actually knew.
Ffred answered:
snip
> Given that Marchbanks is that much older than Dumbledore, it's not
> impossible that Dippet was already Head when Dumbledore went to
school in
> the 1850s, perhaps aged about 100 when he took on the job..
>
> It's not explicit as to whether there was another Head between
Dippet and
> Dumbledore.
>
> I'd go for a minimum of one, but more likely two
Potioncat wonders again:
Well, as I make it out, and I'm as good with math as JKR is, Phineas
Nigellus could have been born born around 1815. (One of many possible
dates) That makes him only about 25 years older than Dumbledore. I
wonder if PN was the Headmaster before Dippet? Although, he seems too
young, doesn't he? Or could he have been between Dippet and
Dumbledore?
You would think if he was too long ago, Sirius wouldn't know much
about him. And for that matter, I wonder how Sirius knew PN was so
unpopular?
Here's how I came up with a possible date. For an arbitrary reason, I
made most of the generations 30 years. That's on the older side. I
also made Sirius' parents older than that, given that Mrs. Black is
an elderly witch in her portrait.
So: Sirius b 1960, Mr. Black 1915, grandfather 1875, Great-
grandfather 1845 (about DD's year), great-great-grandfather 1815
(Phineas).
It makes sense that DD might have had reason to know several of the
Headmasters either as a student or a teacher or just in the WW. How
does that sound?
And, now it crosses my mind, those Blacks don't live very long lives,
do they?
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive