WW POV and acceptance
Chris
labmystc at yahoo.com
Wed Jun 29 18:42:35 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 131683
> Similarly, I find Snape's method of teaching quite uncivilised by my
>standards, but considering everything else that goes on in the WW, I
>can see that it is not out of place there.
>
> Del
If we discuss Snape's actions from the WW point of view, than I
concede and will agree with you. You have presented your viewpoint in
a more articulate manner than I ever could have, and you seem to have
a great capacity for reason. I have enjoyed this exchange immensely. I
hope we disagree more in the future. :-)
I will concede that if we view morality, law, and standards of
society from a WW point of view, then Snape is more than obliged to
act the way he has been acting. I can only hope that within the books,
these kids learn from his actions and go on to become functional
adults who contribute to change within their society.
Chris
*bowing out of this discussion after being bombarded with more reason
than he can argue against*
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive