Couple of questions after CoS reread
dumbledore11214
dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Thu Mar 3 04:46:00 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 125437
I have been rereading Cos and had couple of questions. I do not
remember those being discussed recently, so if someone could refer
me to the message numbers, I will be very grateful. Tonight
Yahoomort was just too much to handle.
Remember when Collin is petrified and McGonagall and Dumbledore are
having the following conversation:
"It means," said Dumbledore, "that the Chamber of Secrets is indeed
open again."
Madam Pomfrey clapped a hand to her mouth. Professor McGonagall
stared at Dumbledore.
"But, Albus... surely... who?"
"The question is not who," said Dumbledore, his eyes on colin.
"The question is, how..."
And from what Harry could see of Professor Mcgonagall's shadowy
face, she didn't understand this any better than he did." - CoS,
p.181
Now, it is a fact that Dumbledore suspected Tom Riddle back in the
days, right? Does it mean that he knew for sure that Riddle/Voldie
is back in Hogwarts?
If said conclusion is true, does it mean that Harry's struggle in
CoS was also just a test or at least half-test ( I am of the firm
opinion that Philosopher stone was a test and the only thing which
Dumbledore has not anticipated was him leaving school)?
Did Dumbledore know for sure what was going to happen and the only
thing he did not anticipate was Lucius making Board to suspend him?
Second question. When Hedwig brings Harry a Cristmas gift from
Dursleys.
"She nibbled his ear in an affectionate sort of way, which was a far
better present than one that she had brought him, which turned out
to be from Dursleys. They had sent Harry a toothpick and a note
telling him to find out whether he'd be able to stay at Hogwarts for
summer vacation too." - CoS, p.212, paperback.
Let's assume that Dursleys were serious when they wrote a note. We
all know the drill about Harry's protection, right? Does it mean
that Dursleys were not informed about the nature of the protection
by Dumbledore? That he definitely must spend some time there.
Does it mean that Dumbledore was still keeping secrets at the end of
OOP and Harry does not necessarily have to return to Dursleys every
year and can skip a year or two.
Does it mean that Dursleys were hoping that protection deal will
stop when Harry goes to Hogwarts?
What does it mean?
Alla
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive