SHIP: Ginny and Harry. AND Would Ron really be the one for her?
dumbledore11214
dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Sat Mar 5 05:31:15 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 125531
Tonks:
So it would
follow that if Harry ends us with a girlfriend it will be Ginny.
Hence a new Adam and a new Eve restored to eternal life. I know
this sound far fetched, but it is JKR we are dealing with here.
GEO: The problems I've with his relationship is that it's not one of
equals (Ginny is taken over by a mere shadow of young Voldemort's
spirit while in contrast Harry battles Voldemort and his spirit and
survives numerous times including being taken over briefly by the
inherent qualities within himself). I would rather have Harry ending
up with someone thats more of his equal like Hermione or even
perhaps Luna.
Alla:
I don't know if I buy Tonks analogy, but I tend to agree with her
that if Harry ends up surviving ( pretty pleae, JKR:o)) and with
girlfriend - it will be Ginny or Luna or any other secondary
character ( Parvaty, Susan Bones,whoever). Simply because to me text
SO clearly points to Ron and Hermione. I just think that Hermione
is "taken' in JKR's mind. Could be wrong, but as I said again,
whoever makes Harry happy is fine with me, I don't really care
much. :o)
What I do disagree with is that Harry and Ginny are not equals.
Ginny is the ONLY one who understand what does it mean to have
Voldemort in her head, so she clearly knows what Harry is going
through
And she was not just taken by Riddle. She thought against him
bravely. She after all tried to tell Harry what is going on even
when Riddle was getting stronger and stronger and if Percy did not
show up, maybe she would. So, she did not allow Riddle to make her a
complete zombie.
As to final fight in Chamber, that was the classical "hero saving
beatiful maiden" fairy tale moment, IMO.
Just my opinion,
Alla
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive