[HPforGrownups] Re: Hermione's a liberal

[Kathryn]

No: HPFGUIDX 125609

 

 
"Kathryn" wrote:
 
> You cannot simply impose rules on
> people and claim it is a culture.
 
Eggplant
You can if the vast majority of people think those imposed rules are
absolutely wonderful, in the case of NAZI Germany at one time or
another the vast majority of people thought Hitler was the best thing
since sliced bread, 

K

Still doesn't make it a culture it's a political system/philosophy. 


 
> I couldn't remember if he [Kreacher]
> was still at Grimmauld Place now that
> his master (Sirius) was dead or if he
> had automatically gone to the next
> member of the family still alive which
> would, I assume, be Narcissa.

Eggplant 
Book 5 didn't say but I predict in book 6 we will find that Sirius
left Grimmauld Place to Harry making him Kreature's master. Harry
might then quite literally order him to jump off a cliff.
 
K

I'd be surprised if Sirius can have left the house to Harry since he
probably hasn't had time to make any kind of will since he got out of
Azkaban and I doubt Harry was his heir before the incident at Godric's
Hollow and besides that we don't know if Kreacher would be able to be passed
on like that. If house Elves are tied to a family (which seems as likely as
being tied to a particular house) then he's probably gone to Narcissa.

K

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]