News Flash! HBP covers released!
greatelderone
greatelderone at yahoo.com
Wed Mar 9 17:05:53 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 125783
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Hannah" <hannahmarder at y...>
wrote:
> Hannah: Lack of relevance? Well, the front cover of UK PS shows
> the Hogwarts express - not the most vital plot element in that
book,
> and that of UK CoS shows the flying car - again, not terribly
> relevant to the ultimate plot, though great fun.
GEO: But I don't believe those initial books had adult editions so
those examples aren't really comparable in my opinion.
> I don't think the other pensieve scenes have been irrelevant
> either. In GoF, it told the backstory of Crouch and his son,
which
> was very very relevant. It revealed the fate of the Longbottoms.
> It told us Karkaroff was a DE, and that Snape was a spy vouched
for
> by DD. It introduced the Lestranges. It set the scene for what
> things were like during the first war.
GEO: But do you think the courtroom scene in GoF or the flashback to
the Hogwarts of Snape's time would have made a good cover for Goblet
of Fire or Order of the Phoenix? I for one think they wouldn't have
and would have been very misleading if the publishers actually did.
They may be relevant and important to the plot, but certainly not
coverworthy.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive