All the possible OWLS

[Hannah]

No: HPFGUIDX 125795


Amy wrote:

> I have often asked myself this same question.  I mean if anyone is
> going to get 12 OWLs it will be Hermione.
> 
> I like your idea that maybe there are different types of OWLs 
within
> each subject.  I truly believe that this would make the most since 
and
> would simulate our own educational testing.  However, another 
theory I
> have is that you don't have to take a class to take the OWL on it. 
> Meaning that Hermione can still take the Divination OWL even though
> she dropped the class.  Only the truly dedicated witch\wizard would
> even attempt to go for 12 OWLs and those that do are probably 
talented
> enough to get it.  Some of the OWLs such as History of Magic,
> Mugglestudies, and even Divination could technically be achieved by
> reading books instead of taking the class.

Hannah again now:  I'm glad someone thinks my alternative OWL 
theories make sense!  I've heard the idea that maybe clever students 
like Hermione could take OWLs without attending the classes before.  
I suppose it is possible (and I know it can be done in the RL, 
though it makes you pretty unpopular with those who attend the 
classes).  

The only problem is that Hermione had her Arithmancy exam at the 
same time as Ron and Harry had Divination, suggesting that some 
subjects (presumably those in the same timetable slots at the 
school) are incompatible.  So even if Hermione wanted to do 
Divination, she wouldn't be able to (unless she was kept in 
seclusion and did the exam after everyone else, which again happens 
in the RL).  I guess if she was going to do anything extra, it would 
Muggle Studies, which shouldn't be too difficult for a Muggleborn to 
pass.  

I still think that it must be possible to get 12 OWLs without having 
to take extra regular subjects.  If anyone can do it, it's got to be 
Hermione, and she doesn't seem to be using that method in canon.  
Just another thing we'll have to wait for HBP to find out (though I 
suspect that all this could stem from JKR's mathematical problems!)

Hannah