All the possible OWLS - Who got what?

Steve bboyminn at yahoo.com
Sat Mar 12 17:14:26 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 125963


--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Kate Williams
<kayt.williams at b...> wrote:
> 
> bboyminn:
> 
> Based on my best quess, ...
> 
> So, 6 OWLs most likely, and 8 at the absolute most for Harry, and 6,
> possibly 7, for Ron. Not bad, not bad at all. (Assuming one OWL per
> subject.)



> Fitzov:
> Has anyone considered the possibility that Harry fails Defence
against the Dark Arts?  I have long held the suspicion that ...
Umbridge... has just intervened to fail him.  Possibly she placed the
examiner under an Imperious curse?
>  
> If Harry does fail, then I am willing to guess that there is no
justice in the Magical World that would enable Harry's mark to be
reinstated.  This would entirely mess up his future career as an Auror.
>  
> Any thoughts.
>  
> Fitzov

bboyminn: 

Interesting thought, but in light of Voldemort's /confirmed/ return, I
think in the next book, the Ministry, and by extension Umbridge, will
have fallen into complete disgrace, and will have very little time or
power to affect anything before they are thrown from office.

In addition, I think everyone at Hogwarts knows that Umbridge was
corrupt, and actively and aggressively gunning for Harry.
Consequently, even if Umbridge has somehow managed to fail Harry in
DADA, I think Dumbledre and the staff at Hogwarts would fight to get
his grade changed to something more realistic.

Also, remember that during the exam Harry produced a Patronus Charm
which was witnessed by several examiners and other students. So
Umbridge would have had to not only control one of the examiners but
erase the minds of the others as well.

All that said, I wouldn't put it past Umbridge to try some sneak
underhanded means of messing with Harry's grades in a last desperate
attempt to discredit him. Fortunately, I don't think Dumbledore, the
school staff, or Harry would let her get away with it. 

Perhaps, this last desperate attempt on Umbridge's part to discredit
Harry will be the means by which Umbridge is held accountable and
force to pay for the evil she perpetrated during her time at Hogwarts.

Time will tell.

Steve/bboyminn









More information about the HPforGrownups archive