Dung as Spy? (Was Re: Lily's physical description, and a bit more apparently :-)

[mhbobbin]

No: HPFGUIDX 126003


--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, adesahafford at w... wrote:
> 
> In a message dated 3/12/05 9:25:42 AM Central Standard Time, 
> HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com writes:
> 
> 
> > Just imagine if he knew of the prophecy (maybe he was the one 
thrown 
> > out of Hog's Head?) 
> 
> I'd always assumed that was Mundungus. Didn't Lupin or Moody say 
Dung hadn't 
> been allowed at the Hog's Head for nearly 20 years, and that's why 
he had to 
> be disguised to overhear the DA formation meeting.
> Adesa 
> 

mhbobbin:
I've always wondered if it was Dung as well for this reason. BUT--
why would DD have Dung (who is part of the old gang mentioned at end 
of Goblet of Fire) in the Order, if he was this particular spy. He 
was likely already in the Order when the Prophecy was given (it 
being only a bit more than a year before the end) and yet Aberforth 
threw him out.

I do believe that DD must know who the spy was, given that Aberforth 
discovered the spy.

I think we're probably all a bit distrustful of Dung, given that his 
name was linked with Umbridge in the Fred and George gag, and other 
behaviors. Dung is only loyal to Dung I think. Anyway, I suspect 
Dung is some king of spy now but wasn't The Prophecy Spy.

mhbobbin