Watching tasks 2 and 3 (wasRe: Dumbledore the teacher)

cubfanbudwoman susiequsie23 at sbcglobal.net
Thu Mar 17 02:44:08 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 126199


Steve:
> I think Bagman who was commentating, and who was likely in the top 
> box probably had the best view. In addition, the Cup seemed to be 
> in a well lit clearing in the middle of the maze. So it should 
> have been well visible by most people.


SSSusan:
Oooooh!  Does this possibility provide additional fodder for those 
who think Bagman is really one of the baddies?  Could he have been 
in on Crouch!Moody's plot?  IIRC, after Bagman blows his whistle for 
the third time, signalling Fleur's entry into the maze, we don't get 
any further info on where Bagman is sitting or what he is saying.  
Leaves a lot of this open to speculation.  So from a vantage point 
such as Steve suggests -- esp. if he was the only one up there -- 
Bagman could report some of the action, elect to not report other 
aspects of it, basically cover for C!M, couldn't he?  

Or am I just tired & not thinking properly?

Siriusly Snapey Susan








More information about the HPforGrownups archive