Does Trewlawney Know About the Prophecy?

[M.Clifford]

No: HPFGUIDX 126210



> ---> Angie wrote:
> > > I find it interesting that the only two people who have 
> > > witnessed  her predictions are Harry and DD.  What is the   
> > > mysterious connection b/w her and them that "triggered" the 
> > > prophecies?
> > > 
> > 
> > Valky replied:
> >  
> > <major snip> 
> > 
> > Maybe this is also an explanation for the mystery of why Harry and 
> DD heard Trelawneys Prophecies. The connection is between the  
> witness and their own future life - inner being to the Prophecy . 
> > It also begs the question of wether the spy is a Prophecy  
> > instrument too.
> > 
> > Aside: If the spy is a PI then that really leans the bar heavily
> > towards Severus Snape being the Spy.
> > 
> > Angie again:
> 
> Can you further explain what you mean about Snape?  I assume you are 
> referring to him being the person who overheard the first prophecy, 
> by why does it lean the bar heavily toward him being a spy if the  
> spy is a PI?


Valky:
Well first I figure that the eavesdropper was a Prophecy Instrument
because Voldemort would not have shown up at GH when he did if the
eavesdropper had not *chosen* to tell him.
But the choice laid before DD and Harry as prophecy Instruments was
not as simple to make as would be the decision for a devoted follower
of Voldemort to tell him about a threat to his dominion.

What I mean is that, by the reasoning I have used, it follows that the
eavesdropper PI *struggled* with the decision to tell Voldemort just
as Harry struggled with the decision to spare Pettigrew and DD
struggled with his decision to leave Harry at the Dursleys, this all
leans it heavy towards Snape because we know that he betrayed
Voldemort soon after by joining DD.