DD's dilemma (was: Hogwarts Teachers - Lockhart)

[cubfanbudwoman]

No: HPFGUIDX 126300


SSSusan:
> I have never seen a response which really addresses the dilemma 
> many of us think DD faced:  that if he threatened the Dursleys, 
> they could just wash their hands of Harry, say, "Fine!  We don't 
> want the brat anyway."  At which point they could turn him out, 
> send him to an orphanage, call in the Muggle authorities, or what 
> have you.  
 
Alla:
> But are you SURE that Dumbledore indeed faced that dilemma? 
> ... in the text I don't see much indication that Dursleys would 
> have thrown Harry out.


SSSusan:
For me it is the *possibility* that they would have that's enough.  
DD couldn't KNOW one way or the other.  Could he take the risk that 
if he pushed too hard, they wouldn't do so?

The Dursleys were under no obligation to keep Harry.  You mention 
that we get no indication they would have thrown him out.  I happen 
to believe that DD "sweetened the deal" by offering some sort of 
protection to the Dursleys in exchange for their taking Harry in, 
hoping they'd be more willing to do so, but we don't know that yet 
either.  I think this was an extra step that DD likely took to help 
ensure the Dursleys would keep Harry, but it would be no guarantee 
of their doing so.

Again, while there is no indication that the Dursleys would for 
certain bail out if DD pushed too hard or threatened them, isn't it 
a distinct possibility?  And a possibility that made it risky for DD 
to press them hard?

Siriusly Snapey Susan