DD's dilemma - Protections and Perspectives

[Karen Barker]

No: HPFGUIDX 126415



Lupinlore wrote:
<snip> 
>JKR just isn't the best in the world when it comes to keeping track 
>of implications and details.  If it doesn't directly concern the  
>storyline she has envisioned, she tends sometimes to slide over 
>things, leaving all sorts of tangles and confusions and objections 
>in the wake of her pen.

Karen:  And never forget, she thought she was writing a story for 
children.  I don't suppose she ever envisioned her books being 
psychoanalized to the Nth degree, by hundreds of pedantic obsessives 
(I'm including myself in that description, LOL) stretching from one 
end of the globe to the other!

I know this is not stricty canon, but neither is what I am 
responding to and I do think that this is an important point that is 
often forgotten when people start getting heated.

Karen