How Did DD Get It? (Re: The curious silver instruments)

[someoneofsomeplace]

No: HPFGUIDX 126660



Magda:
> I assume that the two smokey serpents are somehow Voldemort and 
Harry
> and that Dumbledore is confirming that Harry is still Harry and not
> taken over or possessed by Voldemort... 
> I think there's been a growing fear on Dumbledore's (and Snape's)
> part since COS that the mental connection between Harry and 
Voldemort
> could go very toxic someday.
> 
> This - imo - is what the instrument DOES; how it actually WORKS, 
well
> it's magic after all.


John: 
That seems the most obvious and logical explanation. My question is, 
how would DD have obtained such an instrument? Did he somehow 
capture a piece of Harry `n Voldy-shared-essence direct from the 
scene at GH?

I'm still suspicious, you see; whenever JKR declines to shed light 
on something so conspicuous as this, something that even *Harry* 
wondered about, that would seem reason enough to suggest that she's 
up to her old tricks again; laying indecipherable clues about 
crucial, but as yet un-revealed, information.   

Anyone else want to throw up some suggestions out of left field here?

John.