The Droobles Blowing Gum Wrappers - Mystery Solved?

[vmonte]

No: HPFGUIDX 126708


tinglinger wrote:
yes but in the previous paragraph hagrid, in describing what his role 
was the night the Potters died and how Sirius loaned him the motorbike 
says "Dumbledore knew he'd bin the Potters' Secret-Keeper."
This statement is then supported by Fudge.

McGonagall changes directions in mid sentence when describing
Pettigrew. "Never quite in their league, talent wise. I was often 
rather sharp with him. You can imagine how I - how I regret that 
now,,,," She sounded as though she had a sudden head cold."

Hmmmmm - or a sudden change of heart? Did she know something the 
others didn't? If she knew that Sirius was NOT the Secret Keeper, did 
she know that Peter was much more likely to betray Lily and James than 
Surius was? If so why didnt she say anything?

vmonte responds:

Dumbledore only knew what the original plan was. This plan was later 
altered by Sirius and the Potters who never informed anyone else of 
the change. We know this because Sirius tells us that he and the 
Potters made the change. We are also told by other characters that 
they were not aware of the change. 

McG feels sorry for being so tough on Pettigrew in retrospect. It 
doesn't say anything about her being suspicious of Peter before the GH 
attack. 

Vivian