Why did Hermione Lie

moondance241 leslie.s.bennett at lmco.com
Wed Mar 30 14:57:07 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 126785



Reading SS/PS again, I was again struck by the question of why Hermione 
decided to lie about the troll in the bathroom.  Prior to this 
incident, Ron had hurt her feelings so much, she was hiding out in the 
bathroom crying.  She'd been at odds with Harry and Ron about losing 
points for Griffyndor.  Basically, there was not a sign there would be 
a friendship there.  Knowing 11 year olds (I have one), I would think 
she'd be more likely to tell on the boys (even with the risk of losing 
more points) then to lie for for them.  I haven't figured out her 
motivation.  Is it just author license to bring the three together?  
Any other ideas (besides you shippers!!)?

Moondance










More information about the HPforGrownups archive