The Sorting Hat

thyladyanwyn beckimajor at yahoo.com
Mon May 16 01:02:23 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 128986

There has been speculation that the Sorting Hat in somehow fallible.  I 
disagree.  Harry chose to be placed in 'anything but Slytherin' (SS), 
and the only other choice the Sorting Hat gave was Gryffindor House.  
Dumbledore reminded him of that in Book II CS.  

I don't see any other references that would lead me to any other 
conclusion.



~~ Anwyn








More information about the HPforGrownups archive