Elkin's TBAY: Minerva McGonagall Is Ever So Evil!

Chys Sage Lattes yami69hikari at yahoo.com
Fri May 20 02:30:31 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 129195


> > Heidi R:
> > 
 Minerva is also close in age with
> Voldemort, they were possibly together at school (and
> with Hagrid too, which might be an extra reason why
> she jumped to help him). Perhaps Minerva is not evil
> as such, but could it be that she has her own agenda
> against (or even for) Voldemort? Was she in love with
> him? Unlikely, although as a teenager he was
> attractive. We know how much Minerva enjoys Quiddich
> and how ambitious she is for her house to win the Cup,
> was there between her and Tom a sporting rivalry of
> any kind? Is Voldemort even good at flying, or was he
> ever good at it? Was the McGo-Riddle relationship a
> Harry-Ginny, Harry-Cho, Harry-Hermione, or
> Draco-Hermione relationship?
> 


Chys:

Why in the trophy room in JKR's site, is Tom Riddle's name on a 
trophy/award? *has wondered about that for a while.*

Also another note I posted earler, that Yahoo swallowed I think: MG 
Said that she shouldn't have been so cross with Peter in book 3, if 
she had only known. (During a hogsmead visit. They were talking of GH 
and Sirius/Peter incident.) I wonder if that means that at the time 
she didn't know he was a DE? Just beacause you are a follower of LV 
doesn't mean you know all the others who follow him as well. Makes me 
think that she was just nervous in book 4 when crouch was under 
veritaserum, and didn't know how much he knew of her.


Chys






More information about the HPforGrownups archive