Ginny's Sigificance as a Female
gelite67
gelite67 at yahoo.com
Sun May 22 21:57:57 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 129340
I can think of two reasons why we needed a female Weasley character:
1) Not to get into a shipping argument, but if Ginny is to be Harry's
girlfriend, then the reason she must be a girl is obvious, since
Harry
seems to prefer girls.
But why a Weasley? Why not any other girl?
I don't have a firm, convincing answer to this, but I would think
that trust would be a big issue with Harry, and it is easier for him
to trust a Weasley. He is beginning to really know/trust Ginny's
character. He knows and respects her family (well, except for
Percy).
Aside from Hermione, Harry has spent more time with Ginny than any
other girl (even Cho). He can see she has backbone; she has dealt
with exasperating older brothers all her life and apparently often
come out on the better end. Ginny doesn't cry at the drop of a hat;
she didn't dissolve into tears when SHE broke up with Micheal Corner;
she toughed it out without crying when she was injured at the MOM.
Also, she has competence to handle tough situations. We knew very
little about Cho's magical abilities. We're learning more and more
about Ginny's all the time.
So, Harry's girlfriend didn't have to be a Weasley, but I
think it will make it easier for him to trust/rely on her as a
girlfriend because she is a Weasley.
2) Tom Riddle's diary. Obviously, Ginny did not have to be the one
to get the diary in order for Riddle to use it to return, but it
seems that the chances of the diary "working" would be greater if it
came to be in the possession of a girl. Apparently, the person in
possession of the diary had to write in the diary before Riddle could
reply. More young girls than boys keep diaries. Hence, the diary
went to a girl -- a young, impressionable girl, who needed a friend
to confide in.
But why a Weasley girl? Why not any young, impressionable girl?
Because the diary and the COS incidents were also an attempt to
discredit Arthur Weasley's Muggle Protection Act.
There are probably other reasons, but these were the obvious ones to
me.
Others, anyone?
Angie
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive