Apparating Lessons

greenfirespike feenyjam at msu.edu
Tue May 24 19:43:39 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 129411


Tonks_op said:

> If they are going to study Apparating and you can't Apparate in or 
out  of Hogwarts can they study it there or do they have to go 
somewhere else?  Will they be just Apparating from one side of the 
room to another? Is there some sort of a shield on Hogwarts that it 
is just the  *into* or *out of* that can't be done?  ????
> 


Greenfirespike says:

I think you have to teach Apparating outside.  If it is simply that 
you can't apparate *into* or *out of* then why don't Fred and George 
apparate everywhere they can in Hogwarts as they did in Grimmauld 
Place.  And after F&G get to Hogwarts, we don't hear a word about the 
two of them apparating, not even in the common room.

Plus, we have several examples of classes being taught primarily 
outside.  There is Care of Magical Creatures, divination, and at 
least the first flying lesson.  

Greenfirespike








More information about the HPforGrownups archive