Apparating Lessons

festuco vuurdame at xs4all.nl
Tue May 24 21:05:56 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 129418


> So, while I can't say for certainty, other than Dobbie, I think the
> indications are sufficient to conclude, or at least speculate, that no
> Apparation by a wizard can occur within Hogwart's boundaries. One
> could speculate that there is a single room that has been excluded at
> least from the Apparation within the boundaries, and that room is used
> for Apparation lessons, but I personally think it would be much easier
> and safer to simply step outside the gates.

I think one room where apparating is possible makes the whole
apparating barriere redundant. Because almost every child in the ww
has gone to Hogwarts, every child that stayed beyond its OWLs will
know about that room. So an enemy only has to aparate into the room,
open the door and....

I also think no apparating is a way to keep track of the students.
Imagine a nightly stroll or more with your lover, you're both
seventeen, have your licence, apparate out of the dorm, have a bit of
fun in London and be back on time for breakfast with no one the wiser.
Hm, teachers won't like that I think. 

Gerry






More information about the HPforGrownups archive