A riddle that has imortant implications on events in the ...

[Renee]

No: HPFGUIDX 129672

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "tinglinger" <tinglinger at y...> 
wrote:
> Katherine Coble
> I can't seem to get to that document, but historically speaking, 
the
> Royalists didn't use the guillotine.  That was the toy of the 
> Revolutionaries.  Not  sure how this pertains to the Potterverse,
> though...
>  
> Well, they DID use it in so far as they (the Royalists) were the 
ones 
> to directly partake of its particular charms.......  ;-p
>  
> 
> 
> 
> tinglinger
> The exact facts of the dream are not important .... the flaw in the
> story is more basic than that......
> 
> and the particular incident that the riddle related to is the 
events
> alleged to have occurred at Godric's Hollow on that fateful 
Halloween
> night

Renee <briefly delurking, because this is so interesting>:

Is it that no one could know what the man was dreaming because he 
died without regaining consciousness, and therefore couldn't tell 
anyone?

And are you saying that no one could know know what exactly happened 
at Godric's Hollow because James and Lily are dead, Voldemort 
(assuming he actually knows what happened) never told anyone and 
Harry was too young to grasp it (though not too young to remember, 
as the Patronus lessons show)?  

Renee