The Ring and the Hand - Unfounded Speculation

[doddiemoemoe]

No: HPFGUIDX 142372

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Steve" <bboyminn at y...> wrote:
>
> For a long time now I've been thinking that somehow the final 
battle
> and the final solution to Voldemort would revolve around that 
Veiled
> Arch of Death in the Dept of Mysteries. But I could never work out 
HOW
> they would manage to get into the Dept of Mysteries for the final 
battle.



Aww come on....would be so easy to toss a horcrux into the 
veil!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
> 
> Now, farfetched as it may seem, I think I have found a way.
> 
> Notice that the only Horcrux that has been destroyed by Dumbledore 
is
> the Slytherin/Gaunt Ring. Also, note that Dumbledore has a 'dead'
> hand. And where do you wear a ring if not on your hand?

(how dare you ask) *snicker*
> 
> We also have speculated that we don't really have to destroy the
> Horcrux soul-pieces, we only have to release them from their new
> 'bodies'. That is, Harry doesn't have to kill the soul pieces, only
> release them. But how? And how can we release the soul-pieces in a 
way
> that assures that they don't rejoin their master in the 'home-
body'?
> 


I know you'd hate to admit...but can't you imagine harry sticking 
part of his body(head) through the veil!? I can...Luna can...

okay....

Now do you want to hear something comepletely horrible...

Snape may have really had an inclination to the horcrux theory..It 
would make sense...

I think Snape disagreed with DD regarding whether or not Harry was a 
horcrux..(why else the scenario at the end of HBP...where snape 
would not kill Harry!)

I really do loathe Snape..but I think he may have something...

Snape hates the veil...in all probability...Snape probably thinks 
that Sirius is not dead...

I wonder if DD did not stick HIS HAND through the veil.(uh-oh...do 
we need to go back and look at OOP).and I also wonder if Snape did 
not, "stopper death"...after DD may have stuck his hand through..(no 
snape as savior here....he may have did something less)

> Note: in previous discussion, I didn't really care if the soul-
pieces rejoined Voldemort or not; now I'm thinking it might not be 
such a good idea.

On the other "side" we know that all the folk voldie killed..are 
waiting from him...How do we know??? because we know that harry and 
luna heard voices on the other side of the veil. We also know that 
the dead can help due to the prior incantem..

As we know DD before the "dead hand" scenario...who saved dd after 
that...simply Snape...(DD left us loads of clues...)

Why else would McGonnagal ask Harry what happened..

Everyone trusted DD except for Harry....

McGonnagal, Hagrid, etc...all of them trusts Harry more than 
DD...due to DD's insistance!!

(why else would Harry give the answer he did?!?!?!)

Doddie