Harrycrux again (was: Why can't Harry?)

[ronnie]

No: HPFGUIDX 142486

expectopatronnie: 
Neri, I liked some of your explenations, although I'm not altogerher 
sure I'm convinced. But, even if I do go along with you, could you 
explain why *Harry* is the Horcrux, and not solely his scar? Most of 
your argument would still work, but Harry would not have to die, 
only to have his scar removed.

Also, I really don't think the 'monster' or 'creature'words 
concerning Harry's crush to Ginny are of any relevence here. We all 
have monsters and creatures like that inside us (I hope you do 
too!), and none of us are HX of LV!

> Neri:
> This choice of words to describe Harry's crush is slightly 
disturbing,

expectopatronnie: 
JK used the word creature, a lot of other times too. 

Neri:  
> 10. Unintentional Hx: I agree that it wouldn't be very logical for
> Voldy to make Harry a Hx and immediately trying to kill him. As a
> whole, it appears Voldy isn't aware at all that Harry is his Hx. 
But I
> see a very good scenario for unintentional Hx: when he went to GH,
> Voldy was planning to use Harry's murder to rip his soul, and turn
> *Lily* into his Hx. This is why he tried to spare her, which JKR
> recently confirmed. 

expectopatronnie: 
Did she really? Like the rest of us, I've been wondering why LV told 
Lily to step aside, for ages now. Can you give us the link to this 
confirmation? 

E., letting the monster inside her purr with wonder.