Lilly and James

[Steve]

No: HPFGUIDX 142519

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "flyingmonkeypurple"
<tab1669 at e...> wrote:
>
> I was reading the first book again and I noticed that Hagrid 
> told Harry that both Lily and James were Head boy and Head girl
> (page 55 USA). Who would let James be Head boy? ... Any thoughts?
> 
> flyingmonkeypurple

bboyminn:

We've had Head Boy discussions before, and while all UK school systems
are different, in general, Head Boy is not King of the Prefects; it's
more like being top honor student.

Head Boy is a separate honor from Prefect, although logically many
Prefects like Percy become Head Boy. BUT you don't have to be a
Prefect to be a Head Boys, which to me makes it clear that it is
indeed a separate honor. Note that James was not a Prefect, but he was
Head Boy.

I've always equated it with Valedictorian, although that's not a
perfect model. In a sense, Head Boy is 'best boy' or 'top boy' or
'smartest most achieving boy'.  To be Head Boy, is to be honored in
your seventh year as the top student in the school. So, even if you
are a trouble maker, if you demonstrate the skill and get the top
grades, and despite your bits of trouble making, show that you are a
person with significant potential, then you are 'Head Boy'.

Prefects are chosen for responsibility. They are required to maintain
order and assist the staff. Best 'person' is an academic and general
achievement honor. 

I suspect Hermoine would be, without a doubt, Head Girl if she attends
her 7th year. But Harry's grades/marks just aren't high enough to
qualify. I suspect Ernie MacMillan has a good chance.

Also, though I'm sure others will corect me if I'm wrong, there are
two new Prefects for EACH HOUSE appointed every year, but only one
Head Boy and Head Girl for the entire school.

Hope that helps.

Steve/bboyminn