Lupin in Book 7 (Re: The co-protagonists and minor characters...)
Jen Reese
stevejjen at earthlink.net
Wed Nov 9 05:31:09 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 142706
Carol:
> Maybe Hagrid will take care of Hedwig, who's too conspicuous for
> Harry to use as a means of communication, so maybe Harry will use
> his Patronus to communicate with Lupin, who (IMO) will need to
> remain at 12 GP as he can no longer spy on the werewolves (his
> cover is blown--the DEs saw him fighting as an Order member at
> Hogwarts).
Julie:
> I agree Lupin blew his cover, so I'd assume he'll be holed up with
> the Order, or with Tonks ;-) Grimmald Place seems likely. I
> suspect the two of them will join in a battle against DEs at
> some point though.
Jen: I've been thinking about Lupin recently--so glad you two
mentioned that he blew his cover as I hadn't thought of that. For
Harry, Grimmauld must feel like the money he won for the Triwizard
tournament--a burden instead of a gift, and 'won' at a very high
price. Harry will gladly hand over the house to Lupin and Tonks
permanently if they'll accept it. Lupin can remove the rest of the
dark creatures and hopefully the House Elf Wall of Fame, and Tonks
and Hermione will put their heads together and come up with a
solvent for the permanent sticking charms (and sell it to the Other
Minister? <g>).
I have high hopes for Lupin's further development in Book 7. Why
else did JKR leave the last Marauder standing if not to help bridge
the gap between the past Harry is finally exploring and the onerous
task he has left to accomplish? Lupin seems perfectly poised to help
Harry now that Sirius and Dumbledore are gone. I expected to see
this relationship develop in HBP, then realized it made perfect
sense to shunt him off to the werewolf camp with nary a letter, so
Harry could focus on Dumbledore bonding. And I don't think this will
ruin JKR's idea of Harry going on alone because Harry doesn't view
Lupin as someone he *needs*. Lupin's kept Harry at a distance and
therefore Harry doesn't depend on him. Lupin is a proven teacher for
Harry though, and may be important for helping him develop a few
last skills.
There's so much Lupin can do for himself and Harry in this one *Rubs
hands togther with anticipation*. For starters, he could go to
Godric's Hollow with Harry, to put his own ghosts to rest as well as
fill Harry in on vital information such as why Sirius/James
suspected him to be the spy, Lily's and James' funeral, and perhaps
even give us the final piece of information JKR promised about the
Prank.
I'm waiting for Lupin to reveal himself as a Legilimens & find out
how that figures into the plot, especially after the moment between
he and Sirius in the Shrieking Shack: "But then..." Lupin muttered,
staring at Black so intently it seemed he was trying to read his
mind...(chap. 17, p. 344, Scholastic) There's another similar moment
in OOTP when Sirius wants to tell Harry more about the 'weapon' and
Molly is forbidding it.
I *think* his skill will help Harry understand the scar connection
and perhaps, as we debated in the possession thread, any other
powers Voldemort transferred to Harry such as possession and/or
legilimency. Lupin understands the dark arts in a much different way
from Dumbledore, and his expertise will benefit Harry. Hopefully we
will find out where he learned so much about the dark arts and why
he had that battered case for his 'first' teaching gig, while JKR is
at it.
Oh, and finally, Lily. I was so hoping a woman friend would fill us
in on her, but they all seem to be dead or insane at the moment :(.
Nope, Lupin will be the one--I'm convinced after JKR made the
comment "Lupin was very fond of Lily, we'll put it like that, but I
wouldn't want anyone to run around thinking that he competed with
James for her." (TLC/MN 2005) You combine that thought with this
comment: "Alfonso had good intuition about what would and wouldn't
work. He's put things in the film that, without knowing it,
foreshadow things that are going to happen in the final two books.
So I really got goosebumps when I saw a couple of those things, and
I thought people are going to look back on the film and think those
were put in deliberately as clues."
Yep, Lupin loved Lily I think, although in a very platonic way. It
wouldn't surprise me to find out he was 'that awful boy' Petunia
referred to, visiting Lily over summers as a friend before she and
James got together.
Jen, who will be very surprised and sad if Lupin is shunted to the
background again in Book 7.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive