[HPforGrownups] Fidelity of 12 GP :WAS: CHAPDISC3

Ralph Miller papa at marvels.org
Thu Nov 10 20:20:08 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 142815


CH3ed:

I agree with KJ and Steve that the fidelius charm was not lifted with DD's
death. I'm still wondering if Harry would be able to tell anyone who hadn't
already been told by DD of how to find 12GP while DD was alive where 12GP
is now that Harry owns it, but still ISN'T the SK? Any ideas?

RM:
I agree as well that the secret would have to continue, otherwise the ability
to kill the SK and release the secret would make it a pretty useless protection.
 I think it is very possible that the binding carries over to the new owner;
perhaps Harry has to select a new SK? We have other examples of binding
magic that carries over, for example, the binding of house elves to the
inheriting family member when the owner dies. 








More information about the HPforGrownups archive