What would a successful AK mean?
ornadv
ornawn at 013.net
Fri Nov 11 19:45:54 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 142877
>Sydney:
>Snape is saying he
>doesn't want to do something, and Dumbledore is saying that he
>promised he would do and he should do it. Fast forward a little
>further. Harry asks D-dore if he still trusts Snape. D-dore says
that
>he is CERTAIN, that he TRUSTS SNAPE ABSOLUTELY
Orna:
Adding my agreement and association We see DD use very similar
words, when he tells Harry, that he has to make him drink the
potion.
"You remember
the condition on which I brought you with me?" Harry
hesitated
"But what if - ?" You swore, did you not, to follow any
command I gave you?"
.Well then" said DD
." You have my orders". Etc.
So it is quite in the nature of DD and his trusted allies to have
such conversations, when they are forced by commitment and loyalty
to do unthinkable actions inflicting pain, and even death on DD.
>-- Sydney, who thinks evil!Snape is about as likely as an asteroid
>hitting Hogwarts
Now we really reached the impossible, at least as long as Trelawney
is on the divine lookout
Orna
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive