Why didn't Fawkes turn up??
h2so3f
h2so3f at yahoo.com
Tue Nov 22 08:55:14 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 143336
scam wrote:
"So, when the entire conversation between AD and Draco (DM) was taking
place on the castle ramparts itself (IMO, ample time for Fawkes to
have
sensed danger to its master), why didn't Fawkes turn up?" <snip>
CH3ed:
I think Fawkes was standing down from the whole confrontation on DD's
order. It would make sense with the theory that DD and Snape had
anticipated the possibility of the tower scene happening (not in exact
details, of course), and DD made Snape promise to sacrifice DD to safe
Malfoy (from becoming a murderer or be murdered himself by DE's on
LV's order) and Harry and the rest of the student. The DDM Snape
didn't like the plan, hence the argument between him and DD in the
forest that Hagrid overheard.
The other possibility is that Fawkes was engaged on a mission
elsewhere all evening(or he would probably have gone with DD and Harry
to the cave) and didn't get back until too late.
CH3ed
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive