Sorting Hat Never Wrong..

[doddiemoemoe]

No: HPFGUIDX 143384

Of course it isn't...

For the most part, the story is told through Harry's eyes..

If Harry is a horcrux it would explain the Sorting hat incident..

However,

If Harry is not a Horcrux...then Slughorn may be a redempbtive 
character

Or,

More likely:

Voldie moldy made the sorting hat a horcrux..

Voldie may have put a portion of his soul in his hat....but if he 
did, then it would be ONE of Four other portions...

Why on earth would Fawkes bring the sorting hat??!???
(perhaps a four on ONE experience in sorting hat universe?_

Harry received a gryphindor artifact..(why? Well, I don't know 
either)

This would make so much sense...hence in COS...16 y.o. horcrux never 
viewed Fawkes, nor the sorting hat, nor Tom Riddle for that matter 
much of a threat!

Voldie wants to be a Phoenix...but he is not..and he can never be 
one because one must still care for "fledgling phoenix"...hence the 
PS wouldn't have been much more use to him.


But when we look at things like trust and love...(well we can get 
into a whole new tonks/remus issue there)...These are aspects that 
make Fawkes and the PS so powerful...due to love and trust...the PS 
wouldn't work because in book one...Quirrell wanted it for 
himself..and could have had it..because he would have had someone 
who loved him. Voldemort knows about the power of love..but he wants 
to escape it..

JK and DD are corect LOVE will save Harry..

LV may have the knowledge to hatch a basilisk...but we know he will 
never know how to hatch a phoenix..

Harry may be a great deal of things...and so may the sorting hat...

And it really would be so fitting if horcrux Harry, beat the horcrux 
Sorting hat...better yet...if Harry beat "horcrux sorting 
hat"...better yet...if Horcux harry, beat the Horcrux sorting hat
(wich I would believe)..

doddie,

(who believes the gleam in DD's eye was that he thought the "blood 
letting" to bring Voldy back compromised the horcrux in some 
way....hence DD never told Harry how his hand was blackened...yet 
the horcrux ring was destroyed...We know Harry can kill 
Nagini..because Harry viewed arthurs attact....it will not take so 
much second time around)