What does Slughorn knows about Dumbledore's injury? WAS: Re: CHAPDISC: HBP4

[potioncat]

No: HPFGUIDX 143417

 
> Miles:
> But here you leave the ice of canon and completely walk on the 
water of
> speculation. 

Potioncat:
Oh, absolutely! This is pure speculation, and it's all Alla's fault 
with that question of hers! It never crossed my mind before. Once 
Thanksgiving Dinner is made, eaten, cleaned up and recovered from, I 
hope to go back and look at any canon on Dark Marks and who can cast 
them. I also plan to do my next read of HBP with an eye out for 
Slughorn. (Anyone who time before is welcomed to go ahead and report 
back ;-)

I haven't forgotten who was in Slughonr's memory. Sluggy was pretty 
thick with several pre-DEs. And I'm wondering if he hasn't collected 
someone who actually collected him!

Potioncat, who positively must go make the pumpkin pies. Does anyone 
have a recipe for Pumpkin Juice? My youngest is driving me crazy 
about it. And may all of you, whether or not you celebrate 
Thanksgiving, have much to be thankful for!