PoA - Snape knew?

[ornadv]

No: HPFGUIDX 143472



>Whiz: Ohyes! Lots of ideas. Snape is amazing! But in a nutshell, I 
>think
>Snape confunded Trelawney to produce both of her "prophesies" that 
>his main
>motive is to destroy the marauders as well as both Dumbledore and 
>Voldemort and
>return the control of the magical world to purebloods, as Slytherin 
>desired

Orna:
So you mean to say, that the real dark character of the books is 
Snape?

Interesting theory. I find it hard to believe, that the motivating 
force of all these books turns out to be some teenagers grudge – to 
get rid of the marauders, don't you think so?

Anyway, I read your links, and I agree Snape can be suspected of 
helping Crouch jr. to murder senior. But OTOH it fits well with 
Snape's sadistic behavior towards Harry, and his hatred for Harry's 
special relation to DD. That's also why he wouldn't feel comfortable 
with Moody hinting that he will tell DD that Snape has got it for 
Harry. Although he isn't guilty of putting Harry's name in the 
goblet, he is guilty of trying to get Harry expelled. And another 
thing - wouldn't the interrogation of Crouch jr. reveal something of 
this accomplice he had in Hogwarts?


>Whiz:
>I'll take it a step further. I believe that Snape's animagus is an
>insect, a buzzing insect to be precise. And I'm toying with the idea
>that he's Draco's godfather, though I'm fuzzy on that one.

Canon everywhere. If you're really interested, I'll start rounding it
all up.

Orna:
I'm very interested. And since when is Snape an animagus? And why 
are you so convinced Snape knew about Wormtail? We don't know when 
he was supposed to change sides. It should be sometime after the 
prophecy. So Wormtail might not even been used than as a spy. 

Orna, confused and intrigued (hopefully not confounded) by this new 
theory