Spinner's End ---- From a different perspective
Bart Lidofsky
bartl at sprynet.com
Wed Nov 30 02:58:24 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 143726
lucianam73 wrote:
> Thanks, I didn't know 'spinner' could mean a liar (I'm not a native
> english speaker, so I miss some things).
>
> That would be very interesting, if Snape is 'spinning' his web of
> lies, who is he trying to fool? If he's fooling Bellatrix in Spinner's
> End, he could be on the right side.
>
> Your idea of the spinner ending in Dumbledore's death is good, I
> think, and very much to JKR's tastes. She likes her double meaning,
> doesn't she?
>
> I had never thought the title of this chapter was meaningful, thanks
> for the clue!
Bart:
I just reread the chapter. I noticed (maybe I was careless, though)
that the name, "Spinner's End" doesn't occur within the chapter.
In addition, "spin" can be used to telling the truth in a way as to
make it imply something which may or may not be true. An example I often
use is, "Joe refused to wear a tie to work, and he was fired." It's
actually a true statement, and happened in a company I worked for.
However, if you think that Joe was fired BECAUSE he refused to wear a
tie to work, then you are mistaken; he was a janitor, and didn't have to
wear a tie. He was fired for stealing equipment.
Reread the chapter, think of Snape as loyal to the OOP, and
concentrate, not on what Snape says, but on what Snape DOESN'T say.
Bart
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive