Harry IS Snape!

[nrenka]

No: HPFGUIDX 141089

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "esmith222002" <c.john at i...> 
wrote:

> Hmmm! I'm very interested in this. How could Snape have provided the 
> information that led to the murder of Sirius Black. As I remember it, 
> Kreacher sent Harry to the MOM whilst Sirius was elsewhere in the 
> castle. Snape then provided the information to the Order that led to 
> their arrival at MOM to assist Harry (if we believe DD). Even if 
> Snape was trying to lure Sirius to MOM, his actions ensured the rest 
> of the order and DD turned up and thwarted Voldemort. 

There's another option, although this is a complete hypothetic.  
Dumbledore tells us that Kreacher went to Narcissa, and told her all 
kinds of damaging material that Voldie used to concoct the plot.  But 
we have nothing to contraindicate Snape doing something along the same 
lines--something that Dumbledore wouldn't necessarily have known about.

I know there is no evidence for this, except for Snape's claim of 
involvement in Sirius' death.  Narcissa doesn't dispute this claim, nor 
does Bellatrix: several explanations, of course, but one of them is 
that it's true.

-Nora is skilled at the devil's advocate position from experience