[HPforGrownups] Re: Harry IS Snape!

Mira anurim at yahoo.com
Mon Oct 3 19:23:20 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 141092


--- esmith222002 <c.john at imperial.ac.uk> wrote:

> Hmmm! I'm very interested in this. How could Snape
> have provided the 
> information that led to the murder of Sirius Black.
> As I remember it, 
> Kreacher sent Harry to the MOM whilst Sirius was
> elsewhere in the 
> castle. Snape then provided the information to the
> Order that led to 
> their arrival at MOM to assist Harry (if we believe
> DD).

By telling Voldemort about the deep love bond between
Harry and Sirius. Which Voldemort would have known
anyway, if we believe Dumbledore when he says that the
reason why he did not speak to Harry at all, not even
look at him, was that he did not want Voldemort to
realize the connection between them. Sirius did not
take such precautions, so Voldemort would have known
anyway how much love there was between him and Harry.
So the jury seems still out on how much this point
incriminates Snape.

Mira


		






More information about the HPforGrownups archive