Motivations for Joining DEs (Was: Bullying)

[a_svirn]

No: HPFGUIDX 141181


> Carol:
>> Granted, a number of spells (notably "Obliviate!") are also subject 
to
> abuse, but they also have other uses (the MoM protecting itself from
> notice by Muggles or protecting Muggles from their own traumatic
> memories). I'm not justifying the use of "Obliviate," which I
> personally think is as much a violation of subjectivity as Imperio;
> I'm just saying that there are excellent reasons why Imperio, like
> Crucio, should never be used. 
> 
I am genuinely puzzled by this logic. If one spell that violates one's 
personality has its uses, than why not employ another one? Or is it 
just because it is mostly used on muggles? Then why not go ahead and 
use the other three on them? Wait, I know why, it would be a breach of 
the Stature of Secrecy. 
a_svirn