Emmeline: As dead as we think? (was Harry IS Snape!)

[quigonginger]

No: HPFGUIDX 141185

Deb (djklaugh) wrote:
> LOL good one Ginger!! I like this and think you may be right ... in 
> essence if not in the way her "death" was actually accomplished 
> (though to my eyes your theory is very plausible). I also think a 
> similar "fate" might have befallen Amelia Bones. 

Ginger:  
Thanks!  
Actually, I think Amelia is dead.  She's pretty darn important in the 
WW, and, as you said, Fudge claims LV did her in himself.  Also Snape 
doesn't mention her, which I take to mean he had nothing to do with 
it.  As far as we know, she's not an actual order member, so Snape 
couldn't be expected to have any info on her.  Mostly it's just a gut 
feeling that I have.  It seems more than a little mean to Susan and 
the rest of the Boneses.  Then again, this is war. 
 
Ginger snips; Deb continues:
> I've even wondered if there might not be a version of the ROR where 
> all these "hidden dead" witches and wizards are hanging out - 
> complete with kitchen, loo, books, games, and other pastimes. Hummm 
> now if Harry wandered by yearning to find what DD has hidden, might 
> the ROR open for him to this very place?   

Ginger:  
That's funny!  The R&R RoR.  Club Dead.  Or they're all living in 
Beulah, North Dakota with Elvis and Jimmy Hoffa.  Carol, can you 
check Area 51 for us?

Ginger, going to bed now, with a big smile.  Thanks, Deb!