Good writer (was: Harry IS Snape!)

ch3ed ch3ed at yahoo.fr
Wed Oct 5 16:30:48 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 141198

CH3ed:  
I actually like the jarringly different tones among the books. 
I admit I was very tempted to skip the opening chapter half way thru 
PoA's first chapter. Then Harry ran away from home. 
  The characters are now reaching their puberty years. I think JKR is 
actually doing a great job with their developement. I remember when I 
was in my late teens.... It wasn't pretty. I would be very unnatural 
and unrealistic if Harry remains the long suffering and restrained 
youth of book 1 & 2. JKR has made some mistakes, but I really haven't 
seen any major one yet. 
CH3ed.








More information about the HPforGrownups archive