Possible Horcrux?

[truthbeauty1]

No: HPFGUIDX 141208

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "rmiller3rd" <papa at m...> wrote:
> I was just thinking about possible horcruxes, (forgive me if I'm
> missing something, I don't have the books handy and haven't read all
> the messages so I'm not sure if someone has already proposed it), how
> about the cursed necklace Harry sees Draco looking at in Borgin &
> Burkes near the beginning of CoS? Has that been proposed as one? A
> necklace that kills muggles who wear it might be just what LV would
> find funny. Just a thought.


truthbeauty1:

  I see what you are saying, but I don't believe it is really likely. 
When Katie Bell is injured by the necklace it is turned into Snape and 
I am sure Dumbledore gave it a look over. I dont believe that 
Dumbledore wouldnt have noticed had it been a horcrux. However, if you 
take the E.S.E Snape position, I guess he could have done something to 
it that Dumbledore wouldnt have noticed anything. But I.M.O the 
necklace is not a horcrux.