Percy the Prefect
truthbeauty1
rh64643 at appstate.edu
Wed Oct 5 20:20:21 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 141211
I'm sure you guys all know the feeling of re reading the books for
like the 6th time and you just notice a sort of feeling that the
book conveys that you have never noticed before. Well I had that the
other day. I was re reading S.S and I got to the part where Harry
meets the Weasleys for the first time.(Like one of my favorite parts
bc I love the Wealeys soo much) Well I noticed a line where Percy is
responding to the twins taunting him. " 'Oh, shut up,' said Percy
the Prefect."(pg 96 in the S.S)
The way Percy is singled out by Harry this early on is odd to me.
>From the get go, it is like Percy isnt quite a Weasley. He
isnt "Percy the Oldest", Or "Percy the twins brother" He is Percy
the Prefect. Now I think it is pretty obvious to anyone reading the
books that Percy does try to distance himself from the family, but I
dont think I realized how good of a job he was doing until I read
that. Int that same book, Fred and George have to force Percy to
spend Christmas day with Harry and the rest of the Weasleys in
Gryfindor common room. For the rest of his duration at Hogwarts, he
only acknowledges his family when they do something glorious. (i.e
Rons victory over McGonagals chess set, his involvment in the
chamber adventure) Percy only shows concern when something about his
family might bring him shame. (i.e. he forces Ginny to take medicine
because she is looking pale, his anger when he sees Ron going into
the girls bathroom) When Percy starts working for the ministry his
true colors are shown. Another thing I found odd, was as I am re
reading the G.O.F, the whole "Weatherby" fiasco. Isnt it odd that
although Crouch Sr. obviously knows Arthur personally, he cant get
his son's last name correct? ( this conversation goes on in pgs.90-
92 in the U.S edition of G.O.F)I believe that this is all proof of
how successful Percy has been at distancing himself from his humble,
eccentric, loving, good, family. I dont really know what all this
means, but I found it all very interesting. I also use this to argue
that Ron's percieved ambition is in no way comparable to that of his
older brother, as some have argued. Also, perhaps there are some
parallels between this portrayal of Percy, and that of Tom Riddle.
(i.e. only claiming the aspects of his family that are glorious,
such as heir of slytherin, literally changing his name, wiping out
all reminders of his family) These are just my kind of jumbled
thoughts. I would love to see if anyone else had any thoughts on
this topic. If this topic has already been discusses I am sorry, but
I havent really seen it soo far.
truthbeauty1
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive