[HPforGrownups] The Trial Of Severus Snape

[Sherry Gomes]

No: HPFGUIDX 141313

My point is if any, heck, maybe even ALL these arguments were true 
would you consider the mitigating factors? Would the explanations, no 
matter how far fetched, if proved true, soften your judgement?
Or would you really condemn him to Azkaban no matter how heroic his 
actions were proven under harsh circumstances?

Elyse


sherry again:

i meant to respond to this particular part of your post:

You asked if I would condemn him to Azkaban, no matter how heroic his
actions are proven to be.  I'm sorry.  There is nothing, in my opinion only
of course, absolutely nothing, *heroic* about killing a helpless old man and
saving your own skin in the process.  Sorry Sevvy, no explanation can make
you a hero for that one.

Sherry