Harry is Snape

[Claudia]

No: HPFGUIDX 141344

juli17 at a... wrote:
> > I'd say it's very premature to judge the extent of Snape's guilt.

Eggplant: 
> And I'd say in the real world not one person on Death Row has evidence
> against them stronger than what we have against Snape.


And what about the scene where a young, strong, healthy boy forces an 
old, weak and injured man to drink something this old man clearly 
doesn't want to drink, is making him suffer terribly and probably even 
die?

Do we think that this is an evil boy trying to kill the old man?

No, because we know that DD himself made Harry do this and we know how 
much Harry hates to have to do this. No such information is given to us
about the tower incident. Neither do we know what talks DD and Snape 
had beforehand nor do we "see" into Snape's head.

Therefore I also think it's premature to judge.

claudia