A Cold Equation.

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 141375

"zgirnius" <zgirnius at y...> wrote:


> I would agree that Snape has some
> responsibility for the situation,

Some responsibility!? 

> especially if he knew what Draco's
> task was when he took the Vow.

If Snape realizes now that he made a mistake and he must have been
suffering from a massive brain injury to agree to make that crazy vow
and if he really is a good person as some have said then long before
that night in the tower he should have walked away from Draco and his
task broken his vow and died. Dumbledore shouldn't suffer for Snape's
idiotic blonder, Snape should.

But I don't think Snape is an idiot and I don't think he made a
mistake, I think he knew exactly precisely what the ramifications of
that vow were and I don't think he regrets it for one instant. 

Eggplant