Harry is Snape.

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 141403

James Sharman <jamess at c...> wrote:

> There is no way we can know for sure
> that Snape didn't know all that had
> happened in the cave. 

Just a few minutes before even Dumbledore didn't know what was going
to happen in that cave.

> For all we know the information about
> the poison passed between them in the
> first half second and they spent the
> rest of the time reminiscing about the
> good old days. 

Unfair! If you can invent new magic on the fly that Rowling never even
hinted at you can justify any plot no matter how ridiculous, but even
then you can't make it work artistically.

Eggplant