Harry is Snape.

[M.Clifford]

No: HPFGUIDX 141430



> Valky wrote:
> > apart from the witnesses subjective opinion 

> eggplant:
> And the narrator's objective description.

Valky again:
Of a green light and the words Avada Kedavra.

> Valky:
> > what evidence of treachery do we have?

> eggplant:
> Dumbledore's murder.

Valky:
First it needs to be established that it *was* a murder. I stand by my
uncontested statement that this is not conclusively established.


> Valky:
> > I'll answer that: We have the words
> > Avada Kedavra and a green light. 

> eggplant:
> And Dumbledore getting pushed by Snape from the highest tower at
> Hogwarts 

Valky:
This is a very good point. It does corroborate evidence of treachery
on the Tower. It comes very close to proving it. Except that it is
preceeded by the whole dodgy AK fiasco, and mitigated by Fawkes, DD's
loyal pet, keeping his distance, I would agree. 


eggplant:
and [Dumbledore] developing a bit of a speech impediment.

Valky:
<g> I am not sure what that concludes for you, but it certainly
corroborates plenty of other theories as well.

> Valky:
> > This is enough for you?

> eggplant:
> Yep. 


Valky:
Oh, OK. It's just not a very thorough investigation is all.