[HPforGrownups] RE: Wands

[Charybdis]

No: HPFGUIDX 141536

On 10/12/05, Michell Thitathan <h2so3f at yahoo.com> wrote:
>  truthbeauty1  wrote:
>  What I am confused about is that if Ollivander has made L.V a
> new wand, will it work as well as the wand that "chose him". I don't see how
> it would work as well, and I
>  can't see L.V. using a wand that did not suit him properly. 

>  CH3ed replies:
>  I think both LV and Harry would still be using their
> own brother wands to the end.That seems to be their destiny (but I'm just
> speculating, of course).. but as far as we know one would have to have been
> disarmed (or dis-wanded?) or unable to draw his wand and say a curse at the
> same time that he is cursed, for one to successfully kill the other.
> Otherwise the scene in the graveyard would be repeated, and not just one
> bead of light but many beads will be forced by one into the others wand and
> instead of the affected wand just vomiting out its past deeds it would just
> be destroyed altogether?
>


Charybdis responds:
I think for Harry to effectively fight Voldemort one-on-one with
regular magic, he'd have to master wandless magic.  Perhaps this was
why the subject of wandless magic was discussed again in book 6. 
Harry does have some very promising ability to do unconcious magic; if
he is able to master his power wandlessly, he could finally show some
more outstanding magical abilities.

--
Charybdis