Wands

truthbeauty1 rh64643 at appstate.edu
Thu Oct 13 23:46:03 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 141566

Geoff Bannister wrote:
 (snip)
> Moving on to the subject of Dumbledore doing wandless magic, there 
does 
> appear to be at least one case of him doing this. It is not a 
major 
> example but it indicates that he could:
<SNIP of the quote which could be read UPTHREAD>
>> (PS "The Man with Two Faces" p.222 UK edition)
 
truthbeauty 1 again:
   This is an interesting point. However,I was kind of under the 
impression that Hogwarts itself is kind of magic. This 
instance,I.M.O, could just be D.D kind of directing the walls in 
which way to go. That could be completely wrong, however, I still do 
not really believe that good solid magic can be achieved by wizard 
kind without their wands. I also find it interesting that House 
Elves can do fairly complicated magic without wands, and this may be 
the reason they are not allowed to own them. Perhaps House Elves are 
more powerful than wizards. 

truthbeauty1









More information about the HPforGrownups archive