How recently did SS write in Potions book?

[Stephanie McVey]

No: HPFGUIDX 141706

Trekkie wrote:

> Obviously Snape, as the HBP, has been able to not just invent 
> the "silly incantations" ...  with the sectumsempra and the other 
spells he has alledgedly invented.
> 
> There's something here that seems out of tune to me.
 


~aussie / norbertsmummy wrote:

> "Alledgedly" made something click with me. There are inconsistancies 
> in the potions book with teen Snape.

<snip>

Stephanie:

Somethine just occured to me, while reading this post.  Could it be that although this was Snape's book, that someone else was writing in it also.  Perhaps a potions study partner?  Maybe HBP was someone's (Lily's??)  nickname for SS and that this person wrote it in the book.  If I recall, it was written in a "feminine hand".   
 
Stephanie