Dumbledore's "peaceful expression? (was: Dumbledore's pleading)
nkafkafi
nkafkafi at yahoo.com
Sun Oct 16 23:02:20 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 141717
> > Carol:
> > However, the blood is not the only incongruous detail that
> requires an
> > explanation. So do the closed eyes (not seen in any AK victim--
> Cedric,
> > the Riddles), the peaceful expression (I know you've argued that DD
> > had come to terms with death, and I agree, but an AK wouldn't give
> him
> > time to compose his expression--or close his eyes), <snip>
> CV:
<snip>
>
> The smile? There is no way that an AK victim would have the time or
> inclination to smile. They don't even put on a death grimace. This
> was Dumbledore's reaction to his own joke on everybody.
>
Neri:
OK, I must have missed something, because I don't have the time to
read all (or even most) of the posts in HPfGU these days. So can
someone explain to me how everybody knows that Dumbledore had a
"peaceful expression" when he died, or that he had a "smile" on his face?
My book (HBP, US ed, pp. 608-609) describes the fallen Dumbledore as
follows:
************************************************
Dumbledore's eyes were closed; but for the strange angle of his arms
and legs, he might have been sleeping. Harry reached out, straightened
the half-moon spectacles upon the crooked nose, and wiped a trickle of
blood from the mouth with his own sleeve. Then he gazed down at the
wise old face and tried to absorb the enormous and incomprehensible
truth: that never again would Dumbledore speak to him, never again
could he help...
************************************************
I also went over the previous and next pages, and I still can't find
the words "peaceful expression" or "smile". Help, anybody?
Neri
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive